3 D CANADIAN NAT.

Crossbow Hunting

Moderator: Excalibur Marketing Dude

DesertRat
Posts: 709
Joined: Sun Nov 23, 2003 9:04 am

Post by DesertRat »

Read carefully Terry. I said that "IF" I was going to slam, I would have said things such as....

I guess you would rather that no one discussed what happened at the FCAs? Is it slamming to report that certain bows had reliabilty issues during the 80 target shoot? Are we not allowed to discuss the reliability issue of certain bows on the Excalibur website? Yes I was wrong about the Excal bow having a problem. I admit that. You did however conveniently leave out that it happened during a dry-fire and not normal use. I know most manufacturers test their equipment for dry fires but in reality, that is not considered normal operating of the bow. For all we know, that bow could have been dry fired 3 times last week.

As for bashing Middleton bows, I think they are nothing but Excalibur rip-offs. Look at this picture and honestly tell me that they did not rip-off their design from Excalibur!!! Stevie WOnder could see that!!!

Image


I mean come on! They did not even try and make them look different. I may not be a huge fan of Horton, Ten Point or Bowtech for personal reasons but at least those companies tried to introduce some of their own inovations and make a product that is different than existing ones. That bow pictured above is someone trying to make money off of someone elses creation and development.

All this is my personal opinion by the way. You don't have to agree with me but I suspect that the Webmaster here is not going to ban me because I did not jump on the Middleton's band wagon after the FCAs. Brad is a good shooter and probably could have won the tournament using any of the manufacturers bows. If the FCAs were an opportunity for manufacturers of X-bows to showcase their stuff, having them fail on an 80 target course may not be great advertising. I can't help it if word got out about the Middleton bow having a problem. I certainly will not stop questioning the reliability of different bows simpy because you are a Middleton fan and don't like to hear it. No one is asking you to agree or even forcing you to read it. If you want to dispute the issue, well then, that is your option. I do find it funny that you are on an Excalibur website defending Middleton bows and trying to lump the Excal bows in the same disabled list knowing that the shooter operated the bow incorrectly. Further to that, you are asking the webmaster to ban someone who was defending Excaliburs product? Good luck with that!!!

Now, let's go over to the Middleton forum and see what their guys are saying about the competition. Whooooops, I guess they haven't copied that part of Excalibur's operation yet. :roll:
[url=http://avatars.jurko.net][img]http://img1.jurko.net/avatar_17947.gif[/img][/url][url=http://avatars.jurko.net][img]http://img1.jurko.net/725352.gif[/img][/url][url=http://avatars.jurko.net][img]http://img1.jurko.net/01.jpg[/img][/url]
crazyfarmer
Posts: 5250
Joined: Wed May 24, 2006 10:21 pm
Location: Virginia
Contact:

Post by crazyfarmer »

Woody Williams wrote:Guys,

Accuracy at 3D shoots is 90% shooter and 10% bow..... if that my much.

I don't go out and buy a bow by who won what or what TV celebrity hunter shoots or uses what product.

As seen here, Brad won the shoot, not the Middleton or the Excalibur.
well said;) I was about to say the same untill I saw your post.. When the invent a xbow that holds and shoots itsself ill be first in line to buy it.. that way I can sit home while the bow hunts and has to deal with the skeeters and ticks for me 8)

a simple open sight rifle can outshoot a 15,000 dollar rifle if the shooter suks :roll:
xbowking
Posts: 515
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 11:07 am
Location: Tory Hill Haliburton ONTARIO

Re: 3 D CANADIAN NAT.

Post by xbowking »

turkeylips wrote:hi guys.
sorry for the wrong info just want to correct. BRAD INGOLD did win but with a score of 748 not 948 that was my mistake.top10were 1 / MIDDLETON; 2 horton ; 3 horton ; 4 bowtech striker ; 5 &6 hunter 7 middleton not sure of 8&9 10 middleton. there were only 4 excal shooters there they were in the middle of the pack and lower.it was a very poor showing from excal for the amount of shooters out there excal them selfs was only there the first 1/2 day. the excal shooters themselfs were disappointed with there turn out and excal staff over all. the turn out was 260 shooters with 27 x-bow shooters competeing and 4 noncompeteing because they set up the course
Hi all yes i was at the 3D canadian nationals i did use my wonderful excalibur exocet and i shot a score of 706 , Terry & i placed 7&8 so yes an Excal did make the top ten . Dave.
Andre Leblanc
Posts: 76
Joined: Wed Jun 27, 2007 10:08 pm
Location: North Bay Ontario
Contact:

Post by Andre Leblanc »

Congrats to you and Tery on your performance at the Nats. I am sure you have dedicated much time and effort for the results. Having just purchased my Equinox just a couple of months ago, I have no doubt they can hold thier own against any croosbow. Once again congrats.

Andre
Andre Leblanc
Canoe Builder/Owner
North Bay Canoe and Kayak
www.nbcanoe.com
Equinox w/Lumi-zone Scope
Post Reply