So I wrote to Moultrie to find out what they would do about the broken case and if they had any suggestions regarding the batteries.
They wrote back
So not only do they not warranty or stand behind their product, they try to sell me more of their questionable products. The battery thing is understandable but I don't think -10 is extreme tempsthe case is not cover over warranty. But we do have a security-bear proof box you could put your camera in. The cost of it is $59.99 or a new case will be $25.00. In extreme temps. It will affect the battery and hence the operation of the circuit board and sensors. So take out batteries and make sure to put good hot batteries in it.
Their claim was that I overtightened the bungies, which was not the case.
Anyways be warned DO NOT BUY MOULTRIE PRODUCTS!!!!!