jackleg wrote: What is in your opinion the best turkey call and why

I agree with Rich!
I've found in many hunting situations the best call is none at all!
Where I hunt there is a creek at the bottom of a valley. There are only 2 or 3 creek crossings the turkeys normally use.
I set up on the side
away from where the gobblers roost, and in a spot to cover a crossing that has been getting recent heavy use. Usually I'll make a couple calls (with my box call) just at fly-down time to let the gobblers know there's a hen on the other side of the creek, then put the call away and go to careful watching/listening mode. Sometimes it's a long wait, but often one will investigate quickly. It has worked for me several times.
A couple years ago I killed one opening morning that way. I set up as described, made a few clucks, put the call away, and 1/2 hour later was tagging a nice tom. The property owner set up the next day on the same crossing I had used. He's a "constant calling" type hunter, and he soon had one heading for the crossing. That bird didn't cross at the crossing, but instead went to another crossing (little used spot about 100 yards downstream) and circled the location he was calling from. It was very alert, and very reluctant to come in to the call! He finally got a shot at 35 yards through thick underbrush & got the bird, but he had turned (in my opinion) what would have been an easy open shot into a long contest between hunter & prey.
Both methods worked for bagging a bird, but I'll take quick & easy every time.
