We are not even talking apples to apples with this one and this was only thrown in to poke fun. If we were talking apples to apples I would have gone the other way and say compared the broadhead to say a stone arrowhead, but then we are not all Tred Barta either.Same argument holds true for riding a bicycle instead of driving a car. I didn't see very many bikes out there today.
If you are hearing a BIG POP, you are either hearing metal to metal slapping together from the mechanical head or you are hearing the stopping power of a deers hide to the larger surface area of your mechanical head. Neither one being better in my opinion. Seems to me the less noise you hear the better. Less blunt trama but more speed, less friction, and more chance for a pass through.I like hearing that BIG POP that you can only get with a LARGE cut mechanical.
You are correct with this statement too. However I have read too many times of mechanicals failing (and on this forum) for me to try one. This is partly why alot of us read the forum to learn from others so we do not have to go through the same redundant trials.without the knowledge of actually using one.
This all being said I hope Sumner isn't taking this as a shot but as input. I have great respect for Sumner and all of his input on this forum. Who says we can't agree to disagree every now and then.